📍 This article is part of our Masters 2026 Hub — your complete guide to the most beautiful week in golf.
There's a specific kind of panic that hits when the Masters broadcast flashes "TIED FOR THE LEAD" with three holes left on Sunday. Your heart rate spikes. You lean forward. You start doing math you have no business doing — "if he birdies 16 and the other guy bogeys 17..."
And then it happens. They finish tied. Playoff.
But how does a Masters playoff actually work? It's different from the other majors, it's changed over the years, and the history of Masters playoffs reads like a greatest-hits collection of golf drama. Let's break it all down.
How the Current Playoff Format Works
The Masters uses a sudden-death playoff format. Here's how it plays out:
- Two or more players finish 72 holes tied for the lead.
- They play the 10th hole. The 495-yard downhill par 4 — one of the hardest holes on the course.
- If still tied, they play the 18th hole. The 465-yard uphill par 4 with the iconic walk through the pines.
- If still tied, they go back to the 10th hole. Then the 18th. And so on.
- The first player to win a hole outright wins the Masters.
That's it. No aggregate score over multiple holes. No returning on Monday. Just sudden death, one hole at a time, until someone in a green jacket hands another someone a different green jacket.
Why the 10th and 18th?
These two holes are brilliant playoff choices for different reasons:
The 10th is a beast — a 495-yard par 4 that drops dramatically downhill from tee to green. The tee shot is semi-blind, the fairway bends left, and the green is treacherous with severe slopes. It's a hole where par is a solid score and birdie is a statement. Starting a playoff here immediately puts pressure on both players.
The 18th is theater — the uphill walk through towering pines, galleries packed on both sides, the clubhouse looming behind the green. It's designed for a coronation. Making a player walk up 18 to either win or continue fighting is peak Augusta drama.
The alternation between these two holes gives you the gauntlet (10) and the stage (18). It's phenomenal tournament design.
The Old Format: 18-Hole Monday Playoffs
Before 1976, the Masters handled ties differently. If players finished tied after 72 holes, they came back on Monday and played a full 18-hole playoff round. The aggregate score over those 18 holes determined the winner.
This format produced some incredible golf — an entire extra round of Masters competition — but it had an obvious problem: television. Networks didn't want to wait until Monday for a champion. Sponsors didn't want to pay for another day of coverage that might not happen. And players had to stick around, potentially delaying their travel to the next event.
The switch to sudden death in 1976 was controversial at the time (purists loved the 18-hole format) but it was inevitable. And honestly? The sudden-death format has produced more concentrated drama per minute than the old format ever could.
Every Masters Playoff in History (Ranked)
There have been 8 playoffs in Masters history. Here they are, ranked by pure drama.
1. Rory McIlroy vs. Justin Rose — 2025
Why it's #1: Because it was the career Grand Slam. Rory McIlroy had been chasing the Masters for over a decade. The one major that eluded him. He'd collapsed on the back nine in 2011 with a final-round 80. He'd come agonizingly close multiple times. And then, tied with Justin Rose at -11, he stepped onto the 10th tee in a playoff and striped a drive down the fairway.
Rose matched him on 10. They moved to 18. And Rory hit an approach shot that will live in highlight reels forever — a mid-iron that checked up 8 feet below the hole. He poured in the putt. Career Grand Slam. Green jacket. Tears.
It was the most emotionally charged moment in recent golf history. The roar when that putt dropped on 18 might have been the loudest sound Augusta has ever heard. For the full story of that tournament and what led to it, Rory's name pops up throughout our greatest Masters moments article.
2. Jack Nicklaus vs. Tom Weiskopf vs. Johnny Miller — 1975
Why it ranks here: A three-way playoff featuring three of the greatest players of their era. Nicklaus was already a legend. Weiskopf and Miller were both at the peak of their powers. Nicklaus won the 18-hole Monday playoff by shooting 66 to Weiskopf's 70 and Miller's 72 — a masterclass in pressure golf. This was the last 18-hole playoff in Masters history before the format changed.
3. Larry Mize vs. Greg Norman vs. Seve Ballesteros — 1987
Why it ranks here: Because of the chip. Larry Mize — a hometown Augusta kid with no business being in a playoff against Greg Norman and Seve Ballesteros — holed a 140-foot chip shot on the 11th hole (the second extra hole) to win the Masters. Norman, who had a putt to win, missed. The look on Norman's face — pure devastation — is one of golf's most haunting images. Mize jumping and running down the fairway is one of its most joyful.
4. Fuzzy Zoeller vs. Ed Sneed vs. Tom Watson — 1979
Why it ranks here: Ed Sneed led by three shots with three holes to play and bogeyed 16, 17, and 18 to fall into a three-way playoff. That collapse alone makes this one of the most dramatic Masters finishes ever. Zoeller won on the second extra hole, but the story is really about Sneed — who never won a major and never quite recovered from this one.
5. Nick Faldo vs. Scott Hoch — 1989
Why it ranks here: Scott Hoch had a two-foot putt to win the Masters on the first playoff hole. Two feet. He missed it. On the next hole, Faldo made a 25-foot birdie putt to win. Hoch's miss became one of the most painful moments in Masters history, and he spent years being asked about it. Golf is cruel.
6. Mark O'Meara vs. David Duval vs. Fred Couples — 1998
Why it ranks here: O'Meara birdied the 72nd hole with a 20-foot putt to force the playoff, then won on the first extra hole. The playoff itself was brief, but the putt to get there was spectacular — and it was O'Meara's first (and only) Masters victory at age 41.
7. Angel Cabrera vs. Kenny Perry vs. Chad Campbell — 2009
Why it ranks here: Kenny Perry led by two shots with two holes to play and bogeyed both to fall into a three-way tie. Shades of Sneed in 1979. Cabrera won on the second extra hole with a par on 10 — solid but not spectacular. The drama was in the collapse, not the playoff itself.
8. Bob Goalby vs. Roberto De Vicenzo — 1968
Why it ranks here (last, but fascinating): This technically wasn't a playoff because of the most famous scoring error in golf history. De Vicenzo signed an incorrect scorecard — his playing partner had marked a 4 instead of a 3 on the 17th hole, and De Vicenzo signed it without catching the error. Under the rules, the higher score stood, giving Goalby the victory by one stroke instead of forcing a playoff. De Vicenzo's response — "What a stupid I am" — is one of golf's most quoted lines. The rules have since been amended to prevent this exact situation.
What Makes a Great Playoff Hole at Augusta?
If you're watching a playoff in 2026 (and with how competitive the field is, it's not unlikely), here's what to look for on each hole:
On the 10th: Watch the tee shots. The drive on 10 sets up everything — too far right and you're blocked by trees, too far left and you're in the rough with a tough angle. The approach shot, usually a mid-to-long iron, needs to find the correct tier of the green. Anything above the hole is a nightmare.
On the 18th: Watch the body language on the walk up. The 18th at Augusta in a playoff is pure adrenaline — the crowd is on their feet, the pines are closing in, and every step feels like it weighs a thousand pounds. The approach shot to the 18th green, uphill and exposed, is where Green Jackets are won.
Could We See a Playoff in 2026?
The 2026 field is stacked. You've got the defending champion in McIlroy riding the highest of highs, Scheffler looking to reclaim his throne, Schauffele knocking on the door, and a wave of young talent led by Åberg.
When the field is this deep, playoffs become more likely. No single player is dominant enough to pull away, and Augusta's back nine on Sunday has a way of bunching the leaderboard.
If you're building your betting strategy or fantasy roster, keep playoff potential in mind. Some players thrive in sudden-death pressure. Others wilt. McIlroy just proved he can handle it. Scheffler has never been in one at Augusta. That distinction might matter.
The Drama Is the Point
Here's what I love about the Masters playoff format: it doesn't try to be fair. An 18-hole playoff is "fairer" — it gives players a full round to separate themselves. Sudden death is a knife fight. One hole. One moment. One putt.
And that's exactly why it works. The Masters isn't about fairness. It's about drama, tradition, and moments that live forever. Larry Mize's chip. Hoch's missed two-footer. Rory's tears on 18.
That's the stuff we remember. That's why we watch.
Join the conversation
No comments yet